I am writing this letter to add another voice to the debate around the David Horowitz advertisement. First, let me state that I support the Oregon Daily Emerald in printing the ad for two reasons.
The first reason is the freedom of speech argument. It is the same argument we hear over and over again; if we censor one way of thought, what keeps the powers from censoring any unpopular thought? History has shown us too many times the consequences of censorship.
A second reason why I support the advertisement is that this is a campus of higher education, and this environment should challenge us in a variety of ways. We, as a community, should embrace, celebrate and debate different thoughts and opinions. This ad has sparked conversation across the entire campus, and that is a positive thing. Many of us might disagree with the author’s opinion, but it is good to see students, faculty, staff, administrators and community members discussing the issue openly.
I also think this advertisement can teach us a very important lesson in where we get our information. That is one of the skills higher education has given to me — the knowledge and awareness to question the information presented. One of my initial reactions to the advertisement was that people of this community might read this and not question where the data and research came from. And that scares me.
The ad was well produced; it has half-truths mixed in with stereotypes and misinterpreted data. And for that reason it can appear that it has been well researched and the information is valid. One thing everyone that read the advertisement should consider is how it appeared in the paper. Did it require any validated research or editorial scrutiny? I think all it took was $750.
I remember an experience matriculating through my undergraduate years at a historically black institution. Once we had a guest lecturer give a speech on African-American history. Throughout his entire lecture he continually stated that we must educate ourselves, and that we as a society cannot afford to allow mainstream media, textbooks and society tell us what is right and wrong. It was our responsibility to research and question the information.
That is what I hope this ad does for everyone. I hope this ad inspires everyone to do more research and question the information given to us. Today the information is about slavery; tomorrow the information may be something you hold dear to your heart (the environment, health care, politics, education, art, music, athletics, etc.). Regardless, I hope everyone has done the necessary research to make an informed decision.